NYCReview

Old Homestead Steakhouse review image
7.9

Old Homestead Steakhouse

$$$$

56 9th Ave, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points
RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

open table

Old Homestead is even older than Keens and every other steakhouse on this list, having been in operation since 1868. The three-story space is on the Chelsea/Meatpacking border, and the menu is huge. You can choose from over 15 different steaks, but there are two we recommend trying. The Porterhouse here is cooked and seasoned very nicely, though it didn't knock our socks off. We actually like the ribeye here best of all. It's tender, has a ton of flavor, and pairs well with the excellent garlic mashed potatoes and creamed spinach. Finish your meal with the Drug Store Old Fashioned Sundae. The combination of walnuts, chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and really good vanilla ice cream to make the kind of dece

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

The Best Steakhouses In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Steakhouses In NYC

From a few NYC classics to some relatively new spots that are big on TikTok, here are our favorite places to eat a medium-rare porterhouse.

The Best Restaurants In Meatpacking guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Meatpacking

The 12 spots to eat in Meatpacking, if you really want to eat in Meatpacking.

Suggested Reading

Keens Steakhouse review image
8.6
Review
Keens Steakhouse

Keens is a classic Midtown steakhouse filled with historical artifacts. Even if you don’t care about Albert Einstein’s smoking pipe, you’ll have a great meal here.

Peter Luger Steak House review image
6.7
Review
Peter Luger Steak House

It’s easy to convince yourself that you love Peter Luger. It’s steak and bacon and ice cream. What’s not to love? A lot, it turns out.

Delmonico’s review image
Review
Delmonico’s

Delmonico’s is a classic, white tablecloth steakhouse in FiDi that’s been around since 1837.

Bamonte’s review image
Review
Bamonte’s

Bamonte’s is a red-sauce Italian spot that’s been open in Williamsburg since 1900, and things here don’t seem to have changed much since then.