At Odd Fellows, you can get a flavor of ice cream you most likely never knew existed. You might find cornbread, vegan black sesame passionfruit, or olive oil strawberry ice cream. Flavors change daily, although their sprinkles flavor seems to be a mainstay (for good reason), and if you see miso cherry, it’s important that you order it. It’s salty and tangy, and it’s half the reason why we come here.
OddFellows Ice Cream is permanently closed.
Search by Perfect For
More spots in East VillageSee more
PDT (Please Don't Tell)
Please Don't Tell is about as close as you get to experiencing a real speakeasy in NYC.
Yellow Rose in the East Village specializes in fantastic Tex-Mex and homemade tortillas made with Sonoran flour.
More Ice Cream spotsSee more
Lady Moo Moo is a takeout window for ice cream in Bed-Stuy that has perfected the classic cone.
Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop
Even if you don’t live in Jersey City, you should go there just to try the ice cream at Milk Sugar Love.
Emack & Bolio’s Ice Cream
Emack & Bolio’s is a fantastic ice cream place with soft serve and waffle cones covered in rice crispy treats.
Suggested by our writers
Dante is the rebirth of a beloved 100-year-old Greenwich Village restaurant. It’s ideal for a first date over drinks and small plates.
Atla serves excellent Mexican food in a bright, all-day space in Noho. It’s great for a casual lunch or an upscale dinner.
We wish there was a Daily Provisions on every corner, so that we would never be far from their excellent breakfast and lunch.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more