NYCReview

Masalawala & Sons review image
8.8

Masalawala & Sons

$$$$

365 5th Ave, Brooklyn
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

At this point, Unapologetic Foods, the team behind Dhamaka, Semma, and Adda, knows their brand. They serve hyper-specific regional Indian food that you can’t help but describe in great detail to everyone you know for months after you eat it. 

The bar is set (very) high, and their latest spot, Masalawala & Sons, unsurprisingly meets it. This time, they reimagine some of their childhood staples from Kolkata and the surrounding region of West Bengal, and, with a little more breathing room in Brooklyn, the space is also fun to eat in. 

Of all of their outstanding restaurants serving food reminiscent of Indian homestyle cooking, this is the only one where you actually feel like you’re eating in someone’s home. It’s like you’ve been invited to a special family function where you’ll sit under a wedding party’s worth of gajras next to a mural featuring the man who inspired much of the food on the menu (the owner's father). In the back, more rainbow-bright murals surround an outdoor patio, where the people next to you won’t mind if you join the audience watching a waiter shave fresh coconut meat into the shrimp curry at their table.

Masalawala & Sons review image

Masalawala's inventive, mostly Kolkata-inspired dishes deserve a mural of their own. Focus on the first two sections of the menu packed with small and midsize plates that all seem to be competing for best in show. When it comes to Bengali food, fish is king, and the spicy biyebarir fish fry, incredibly airy steamed bhetki, and small bowls of smokey macher dim are all really special. If you want to venture out of the sea, order the keema kaleji. The cardamom-spiced goat and lamb becomes three times silkier after a fresh egg is mixed in tableside.

You’re going to have a memorable experience at every Unapologetic Foods restaurant. But of all of their spots, this one feels the most mellow, like the kind of place where you could pop in once a week and ask a the server how their dog is doing. Masalawala & Sons not only serves spectacular food. It's also a great hang.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Daab Chingri

This dish involves some ceremony. Your waiter brings you half of a hollowed-out young coconut full of fragrant green curry, then proceeds to peel the last of the meat off the coconut's walls. The result is a spice-packed curry with strips of coconut that have texture of fresh noodles. Eat the shells and heads of the prawns for maximum flavor and some added crunchy texture.

Macher Dim

Consider yourself lucky if you manage to get the macher dim. The kitchen makes just a few orders a night, and it’s extremely unlikely that you’ll find this special dish at another restaurant. A sack of fish roe is poached in a smoky, mustard-spiced tomato curry and served with kalajeera rice. We’re not sure when we’ll get to have this again, and we’re already referring to it as “the one that got away.”

Masalawala & Sons review image

Kosha Mangsho

After one bite of this, you’ll kick yourself for filling up on too many small plates. The kosha mangsho comes with tender, smoky braised lamb in a thick, concentrated masala sauce in which you’ll find cardamom, bay leaves, and the occasional bit of bone marrow. Get a side of puffy luchi to eat it with.

Masalawala & Sons review image

Keema Kaleji

Order the keema kaleji and you'll get a super hot plate with minced goat and liver in a thick, silky sauce that gets some smokiness from black cardamom and cloves. Stir in the freshly cracked egg that’s been slowly poaching in the sauce for a super creamy spread to slather onto a buttery pao.

Masalawala & Sons review image

Sabudana Vada

You’d be surprised at how many tapioca pearls they can fit into this vada, bound together by potatoes and given a good fry to make a very dunkable snack. You get a nice crispy outside and gooey inside, with some cumin-spiced yogurt for dipping.

Bhetki Paturi

Unwrap these banana leaves to find a chunk of barramundi that’s been slathered in a spicy mustard paste and steamed until it feels airy, almost whipped. The fish is full of flavor and melts like butter.

Masalawala & Sons review image

Morog Boti

Compared to all the special seafood dishes on the menu, this red chile chicken seems like a boring choice, but it’s really freaking good. We’d order rarer finds first, but if you’re in the mood for chicken, you won’t be disappointed by this.

Rose Milk

Light, airy, and not too sweet, this rose milk will surprise you when you taste the bit of masala mixed in. It's got a unique flavor that isn't at all what we expected, and it's more memorable than any of their cocktails.

Featured in

The Toughest Reservations In NYC Right Now (And How To Get Them) guide image
Guide
The Toughest Reservations In NYC Right Now (And How To Get Them)

Our thoughts on the busiest restaurants in New York City and advice on how to get in.

The 18 Most Exciting Dinner Spots In NYC Right Now guide image
Guide
The 18 Most Exciting Dinner Spots In NYC Right Now

A night out at one of these places—whether it’s for a catch-up with a friend or an impressive date night—feels overwhelmingly of the moment.

The Best (And Worst) Post-Pandemic Restaurant Revamps guide image
Guide
The Best (And Worst) Post-Pandemic Restaurant Revamps

Lots of restaurants are attempting comebacks. Some are more successful than others.

The Best Restaurants In Park Slope guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Park Slope

Home to more than just brownstones, babies, and brunches, Park Slope has a mind-blowing number of restaurants. Here are the best ones.

Suggested Reading

The Best Indian Restaurants In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Indian Restaurants In NYC

From white-tablecloth places to cafeteria-style spots, these are our 28 favorite Indian restaurants in the city.

The Best Restaurants In Park Slope guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Park Slope

Home to more than just brownstones, babies, and brunches, Park Slope has a mind-blowing number of restaurants. Here are the best ones.

Semma review image
9.0
Review
Semma

Want to convince someone you’re really good at choosing date-night restaurants? Take them to Semma, a South Indian spot in the West Village.

Dhamaka review image
8.6
Review
Dhamaka

Dhamaka is an Indian restaurant in Essex Market on the Lower East Side serving fantastic regional specialties that are hard to find elsewhere in NYC.