Llama San review image

Llama San


359 Avenue of the Americas, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

If eating sophisticated small plates in a space that looks like a one-bedroom West Village apartment that costs $4 million is your idea of a good time, you’ll love Llama San. Their inventive take on Nikkei cuisine is consistently very good, and it’s one of our favorite spots for weeknight dinners that feel a little special without moving into over-the-top territory. 

This West Village restaurant draws a chic after-work crowd of people who’ve graduated beyond fast fashion and flash-in-the-pan hotspots. The space feels soft, soothing, and expensive, like a Pinterest board titled “blonde wood interiors.” The bathroom is filled with $80 scented candles and chic little knickknacks. It’s the kind of place to come on a date where you and your beloved can talk in inside voices about whether you prefer East or West coast uni and not feel pretentious. 

You can order a la carte, or choose from a $95 three-course or $108 four-course prix-fixe. The plates are small but sharable, and a few of them will impress even the most jaded New York City diner. The menu changes from time to time, but a few things seem to stick around, like the Wagyu nigiri that sounds like a gimmick, but it isn’t. There’s also a chicken thigh maki, blanketed in a rich aji amarillo sauce, that’s one of the most satisfying bites we’ve had in a while. We’d come here just to sit at the bar, eat this dish, and have a cocktail.  

Nothing here is bad, so don’t shy away from things that sound like they shouldn't work, either: the tofu bavarois with soy, grapes, and white chocolate quinoa is delightful. 

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

The Best Restaurants In The West Village guide image

The Best Restaurants In The West Village

New York City’s Best New Restaurants Of 2019 guide image

New York City’s Best New Restaurants Of 2019

Where To Get A Last-Minute Dinner In The West Village guide image

Where To Get A Last-Minute Dinner In The West Village

The Best Brunch In The West Village guide image

The Best Brunch In The West Village

Suggested Reading

Llama Inn review image
Llama Inn

In 2021, Llama Inn in Williamsburg has loosened up into a laid-back Peruvian spot we’d visit on a random Tuesday night.

Llamita review image

Llamita is an all-day counter-service Peruvian spot in the West Village from the people behind Llama Inn.

Joseph Leonard review image

Conceived in the spirit of Little Owl, this is a tiny West Village restaurant perfectly engineered for surveying action while you eat. Dinner is generally better than brunch, but it's a nice place to dine any time of day.

Infatuation Logo
2023 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store