Sure, the name sounds like a Halloween-themed Escape The Room challenge, but try not to let that throw you off. This dimly-lit Williamsburg bar makes some fantastic cocktails, many of which are rum-based (our favorite, “Two Wooden Legs,” has black rum, sherry, and herbal liqueur). While the ice cubes are branded with a devil’s tail, there’s a red neon devil’s tail on the wall, and most drinks have vaguely ominous names, that’s about as far as this place goes towards having a “dark” theme. For the most part, it’s just a conveniently located bar with excellent cocktails and some outdoor seating on the corner of Bedford and Grand.
More spots in WilliamsburgSee more
Reunion is a low-key Israeli cafe in Williamsburg, and it’s great for a casual breakfast or brunch when you don’t want to deal with a long wait.
Bolero is a Vietnamese spot in Williamsburg where you should sit in the back garden with a date, or order the whole menu with a group.
More Bar Food spotsSee more
The Gin Mill
The Gin Mill is a bar on the Upper West Side where you can watch sports and play beer pong.
Accidental Bar in the East Village is where you should go to learn about sake with a side of snacks.
Suggested by our writers
PDT (Please Don't Tell)
Please Don't Tell is about as close as you get to experiencing a real speakeasy in NYC.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more