If you’re looking for fried chicken and mac and cheese in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, you should be at Katie O’s. It’s counter-service, and there are only a few tables inside - but it’s great for takeout, and if we made a ranking of potato salads in the city, theirs would be near the top. Just be aware that they make their fried chicken to order, and it takes around 20 minutes. So call ahead of time, or hang out in the little dining room and watch sports on the big flatscreen TV while you wait.
More spots in Prospect Lefferts GardensSee more
Errol’s Caribbean Bakery
Errol’s Caribbean bakery makes the best coconut rolls in the neighborhood, and some very good jerk chicken.
PLG Coffee House and Tavern
PLG Coffee House & Tavern is where you go to get a BEC in Prospect Lefferts Gardens.
More American spotsSee more
Lighthouse is our go-to spot in Williamsburg for a casual, kind of healthy, but still impressive meal.
Loosie’s Cafe is the daytime cafe verison of Loosie Rouge, the bar/restaurant/hot French people hangout in Williamsburg.
Suggested by our writers
Parkside is a Neapolitan-style pizza spot in Prospect Lefferts Gardens with interesting cocktails and affordable wines.
Silver Rice does fast-casual sushi and sushi bowls in Prospect Heights. Stop by for a good, quick meal.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more