NYCReview

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image

Jack's Wife Freda West Village

$$$$

50 Carmine St, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points
RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

open table

If you've been to the original Jack's Wife Freda in Nolita, you know the formula: simple, almost healthy Mediterranean food, served to and by attractive people who are all crammed into a very, very small space.

At the new location, everything is much the same. The menu, in fact, is exactly the same. The food, though not revolutionary, is solid. So many brunch spots are either overly ambitious (don't really need pork belly on that Eggs Benedict, thanks) or characterized by watery eggs and hungover waiters, so credit to Jack's Wife Freda for offering pleasant things - a very good Greek salad, some moderately interesting egg dishes - for lunch, every day of the week. Dinner works too, for something uncomplicated like a plain grilled fish or a bowl of mussels, though the environment dies down a little at night. Again, it's same deal as the original, down to the communal table running through the middle of the space. If they wanted to start franchising the concept around the country, it'd probably work.

The one major difference, and this is important, is the size of the place. The new West Village location is about three times the size of the original, which means the tables are much more spread out. In Nolita, you're basically sitting on top of the people next to you. Whether or not you'll enjoy that depends on how much you enjoy hearing the people next to you talk about how a girl they went to high school with now has 500,000 followers on Instagram. We personally say +1 to having enough room for everyone to actually place down their Alexander Wang backpcks. It means you only have to hear the people at your own table talk about people with outsized Instagram accounts. Better, for sure.

The bigger space also means the service is a little less hectic, the seats are more comfortable, and the waits are shorter. In other words: just like the original, but slightly upgraded.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image

Green Shakshuka

One of the most popular brunch dishes here, two eggs are baked in a tangy green sauce. The restaurant's Jewish/Israeli influence comes through with some toasted challah on the side.

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image

Orange Blossom Pancakes

You can easily keep it simple with pancakes too. No one's gonna be mad.

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image

Greek Salad

A simple Greek salad with shredded kale and a big slice of feta on top, this actually might be the best thing here. And you can get it at lunch or dinner.

Grain Bowl

A more recent addition to the menu, Jack's Wife Freda knows its audience, and its audience likes a goddamn grain bowl. It comes with quinoa, vegetables, and an egg.

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image

Salt And Pepper Eggplant

Little fried pieces of eggplant, with a yogurt-y dipping sauce. Always on our table here. Get an order to share.

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image

Whole Fish

This may seem like an ambitious move, but this dish always delivers. A simple piece of plain fish, with a nice couscous salad and green pesto-like sauce. They'll filet it for you, so you don't have to deal with the head. That's the move.

Fish A La Plancha

Another solid dinner move. A piece of fish, usually salmon, over some marinated kale. Kind of like a more refined teriyaki salmon.

Featured in

The Kind-Of-Healthy Brunch Guide guide image
Guide
The Kind-Of-Healthy Brunch Guide

The places to hit when you want brunch, but don’t want to be in a food coma the rest of the day.

The Best Bars In The West Village guide image
Guide
The Best Bars In The West Village

Whether you're looking for a divey piano bar or bartenders in lab coats, use this guide to find a good place to drink in the West Village.

The NYC Brunch Directory guide image
Guide
The NYC Brunch Directory

All the best brunch options in NYC, all in one place.

Suggested Reading

Cafe Clover review image
Review
Cafe Clover

A bright, California-inspired West Village restaurant.

Cafe Gitane review image
Review
Cafe Gitane

Cafe Gitane is the quintessential Nolita place to “see and be seen,” especially if you’re hoping to see some avocado toast.

Jack's Wife Freda review image
Review
Jack's Wife Freda

A good spot for your weekend brunch rotation, but don't rely on it for dinner. Jack's Wife Freda does not get better when the sun goes down.

Meme Mediterranean review image
Review
Meme Mediterranean

Meme Mediterranean isn’t a destination restaurant, but if all you need is somewhere to eat some pretty-good food while you catch up with friends,