NYCReview

Greenpoint Fish and Lobster review image

Greenpoint Fish and Lobster

$$$$718-349-0400
Hours:MON
11AM-9PM

If you read this website regularly, you know how fond we are of fresh fish. Sure, our restaurants serve up some of the best seafood in the world, but New York City is far from a fishing village and doesn't exactly have much in terms of fish markets you'd actually want to hang out inside of for more than five minutes. All of our best seafood restaurants are urban versions of the roadside clam shack or elevated oyster bar, so it hasn't been until right now, at this moment, that we've really started living the life aquatic properly. Greenpoint Fish and Lobster, it's great to meet you.

Greenpoint is where all the dope sh*t happens these days, so it shouldn't come as surprise that it's home to NYC's most legit new fish market and restaurant. You walk in, and it's raw fish on ice for days. Like a really really really small version of Pike's Place in Seattle. Everything they sell is sustainable, which means you can feel good about eating it. We don't live in Greenpoint, so the fish market element, while cool, isn't why we're hanging such a high number on this spot. It's the dine-in menu that's got us all hot and buttered up.

If you like seafood, then G'Point Fish and Lobster will be your new favorite restaurant. We were pretty blown away by how awesome all the food was, from the oyster prep, to the mussels, fish stew, solid fish tacos, and the best damn lobster roll we've had in NYC not named Luke's. It's all housed in a small tile-filled room packed with high tops and bar seats, with great vibes and slick overall branding. It's the kind of place we'd frequent all the time if we lived nearby, and would even suggest traveling for. After all, Greenpoint is a lot closer than the Atlantic Ocean.

Food Rundown

Oysters

They get them in fresh, daily, from both coasts, and will always have a nice selection on hand. Everything about their oyster prep is spot on, from the ice cold temperature of the bivalve, to the excellent mignonette sauce, to the price, which is right: oysters range from $1.25-$2.50, always.

Greenpoint Fish and Lobster review image

Lobster Roll

Listen up. This is the best damn lobster roll we've had in NYC, not named Luke's. A heaping pile of Maine lobster, mostly of that coveted claw and knuckle variety, mixed with only a small amount of mayo, minced celery, lemon juice, and tarragon and served on a buttered and toasted bun. It's about as close to perfection as you can get. The lobster is the star of the show, and the the zesty lemony flavor makes it super crisp.

Greenpoint Fish and Lobster review image

Baja Fish Tacos

The fish tacos have been getting a lot of hype, and for good reason - these are good fish tacos in a landscape of not-so-good fish tacos. Definitely worth an order while you're here. Get the Gloucester fried as opposed to grilled, and ask for extra citrus cabbage slaw, and extra chipotle lime mayo.

Greenpoint Fish and Lobster review image

Fish Chowder

Whoa. Talk about a bowl of soup. Their stew from the sea is phenomenal. Tons of different flavors going on, all of which amounts to a spoonful of happiness.

Spicy Green Thai Curry Mussels

Another favorite, showing some serious Thai swagger here. A bowl of steaming hot Maine mussels, served with coconut milk and spicy green curry and fish sauce. Not your average bowl of fish market mussels.

Fish of the Day

On our most recent visit, it was Porgy, one of our favorite local catches. The fish was great, but the accompanying pepper-tomato slaw action that it came with was even better. Details - they pay attention to all of them at Greenpoint Fish and Lobster, and our stomachs and mouths appreciate that.

Brussels Sprouts

Make sure you get the sprouts. They're crispy and all mixed up in Buttermilk. You're going to need this.

Featured in

.
32 Restaurants Where You Can Eat In Your Gym Clothes guide image
Guide
32 Restaurants Where You Can Eat In Your Gym Clothes

Go forth and eat well in your sweatpants.

Where To Grab A Quick, Healthy Meal By Yourself guide image
Guide
Where To Grab A Quick, Healthy Meal By Yourself

The best places for a solo meal that’s good for you and doesn’t take too long.

The Brooklyn Delivery & Takeout Directory guide image
Guide
The Brooklyn Delivery & Takeout Directory

Want to know which Brooklyn restaurants are open for delivery and takeout? You’re in the right place.

The Best Restaurants In Greenpoint guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants In Greenpoint

From tasting-menu places to incredible takeout spots, here's where you should be eating in Greenpoint.

Suggested Reading

.
Mary’s Fish Camp review image
Review
Mary’s Fish Camp

Mary's still makes an excellent lobster roll, but this restaurant has developed some flaws with age. Hit it for lunch or brunch, avoid it for dinner.

Upstate Craft Beer & Oyster Bar review image
Review
Upstate Craft Beer & Oyster Bar

Upstate Craft Beer & Oyster Bar is the ultimate neighborhood restaurant, with fresh seafood, friendly service, and free-flowing craft beer.

Le Fanfare review image
Review
Le Fanfare

Le Fanfare is not a burlesque show in Paris, it’s a restaurant in Greenpoint from the folks behind Epistrophe Cafe. Go discover it sometime.

Kimchee Market review image
Review
Kimchee Market

Kimchee Market is a small storefront in Greenpoint you should use for all your Korean takeout/delivery needs.