NYCReview

In 2018, a 19-year-old Californian opened a tasting menu restaurant called Gem on the Lower East Side. You were locked into one of two nightly seatings for an aggressively vegetable-forward, 12-15-course tasting menu priced at $155. That was cool. It really was. Even back then, the chef, Flynn McGarry, made you feel like you were dining in the future, but also in his living room. He put hyper-seasonal vegetables on display without forsaking meat entirely, all in a flower- and art-bombed space that feels more like a fun hang than a restaurant.

But now, in 2021, you can experience all of that without committing to a tasting menu. The a la carte options change almost daily, depending on the farmer’s market, and each and every dish will blow you away. Some standouts from a recent meal included emerald green ramp tortellini in broth, lamb and oyster tartare with fried capers, and an entirely vegetarian schnitzel made with cabbage and maitake mushrooms.

While all of that was being consumed, the chef was sitting a table over, having dinner with friends, jumping up every few minutes to take a dessert order or help in the kitchen. We left the restaurant excited for vegetables, meat, and for what the future of dining out could look like.

Featured in

.
The Best Restaurants On The Lower East Side guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants On The Lower East Side

From old-school staples to restaurants changing the dining landscape of the neighborhood, these are our favorite spots on the Lower East Side.

Suggested Reading

.
Winona’s review image
7.7
Review
Winona’s

Winona’s is a natural wine bar in Bed-Stuy that doubles as an all-day cafe.

Francie review image
8.6
Review
Francie

Francie is a fancy Williamsburg brasserie where you should grab dinner for a big night out.

The Tyger review image
Review
The Tyger

The Tyger serves fantastic food from a variety of Southeast Asian countries in a bright Soho space that’s good for groups.

Silver Apricot review image
Review
Silver Apricot

Silver Apricot in the West Village has a secret patio out back where you should bring a date and eat Chinese-New American small plates.