Gaetana’s isn’t a great restaurant. That said, it is a nice and charming one. The space has tiled floors and candles on every table, and the walls are covered in Frank Sinatra memorabilia as well as several photos of little league teams and even a dog. It also tends to stay pretty quiet here, so stop by and eat some chicken parm the next time you’d like to hide from the world. The food is very standard red-sauce stuff, and there’s roughly a 0% chance that you’ll walk away composing a haiku about your dinner in your head - but sometimes you just want to at sit at a small table covered in a white tablecloth, listen to Billie Holiday, and eat some decent broccoli rabe.
Where we've featured it
Search by Perfect For
More spots in West VillageSee more
Mary’s Fish Camp
Mary's still makes an excellent lobster roll, but this restaurant has developed some flaws with age. Hit it for lunch or brunch, avoid it for dinner.
Fiaschetteria Pistoia is a tiny Italian spot in the West Village that’s great for last-second dates.
More Italian spotsSee more
A little Italian cafe and sandwich shop on the Upper East Side near Central Park. We love the sandwiches, but hate how much they cost.
Hearth has been one of the East Village’s best restaurants for over a decade, and it just got a whole lot lighter and leaner.
Razza is a wood-fired pizza spot in Jersey City that’s well worth a trip from New York. Or from anywhere else.
Suggested by our writers
This West Village Italian spot is starting to feel just a tad dated - but the food is as good as ever. Try it for a special dinner, and order pasta.
Via Carota is a walk-in only Italian spot in the West Village, and there’s a good chance you’ll have to wait a few hours for a table. It’s worth it.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more