This Noho bakery is best known for their elaborately decorated sugar cookies, but their crispy-mallow crunch cookie is what we’ll be coming back for. It’s a sweet, sticky, caramel-y affair. The cookie is large, flat, and flexible—the antithesis of their chocolate chip cookie, which is like a softball of thick, chip-studded dough. If you like extremely thick chocolate chip cookies, you’ll probably like that one, too. And those sugar cookies that look like famous people? Also pretty delicious.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.