Extra Fancy is permanently closed

Extra Fancy review image

Extra Fancy


Despite the fact that you can get a very serious dinner here (burger, steak, oysters, etc.), Extra Fancy feels less like a restaurant and more like a neighborhood bar. It’s a spot to meet up with friends for some casual drinks and/or maybe talk to a stranger late at night. They also serve food until 2:30am., so if you’re hungry past midnight, stop by and eat a lobster roll at the bar. This is a great place to either start or end your night, and there’s also a nice yard for summertime drinking.

Suggested Reading

Lobster Joint review image
Lobster Joint

Lobster Joint is a New England-style seafood shack in Greenpoint where you should spend the next sunny day eating a lobster roll at an outdoor picnic table.

Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe review image
Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe

Anthony & Son is the place to go in East Williamsburg for a sandwich so filling you won’t eat for... ever again.

Little King review image
Little King

Little King is a tiny bar in East Williamsburg that’s good for a low-key date.

Ba’sik review image

Ba’sik is a little, low-key bar in Williamsburg with some decent small plates and a nice backyard.