El Quinto Pino review image

El Quinto Pino


401 W. 24th St, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

A while back, we wrote a review of El Quinto Pino and deemed it “suitable” for a [perfect_for slug=“first-early-in-the-game-dates”]First/Early in the Game Date[/perfect_for]. This Spanish restaurant/wine bar from the folks that brought you Tia Pol, Txikito, and La Vara is very good, but we always had some reservations due to the tiny space and the fact that the thing El Quinto Pino has been best known for, the uni panini, can be your own first date worst enemy. Yes, it’s delicious, but it’s also packed with so much wasabi that it’s impossible to eat without tearing up and making ridiculous faces. And nothing says “get me out of here” like a girl who appears to be crying for no reason.

But now we’re happy to tell you that we can fully recommend El Quinto Pino as an excellent spot for a date, food-induced waterworks or otherwise. The reason for our newfound enthusiasm is that they have recently expanded into the space next door and set up a proper dining room with real seats. The menu has also been expanded to better suit two people looking for a sit-down meal, and they even take reservations. We’ve had dinner in the new room a few times now and have been really impressed with everything from the food to the service to the wine and sangria. “El Comedor at El Quinto Pino,” as it’s being called, is also doing lunch and brunch, in case you’re just looking for a first date with a really good sandwich. At least the sandwich won’t talk about its mom the whole time.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Picos Y Taquitos

This is basically a Spanish meat and cheese plate, with big hunks of chorizo, some excellent spreadable sausage, and cubes of za'atar-marinated manchego. Order it and get things started.

Nuestras Bravas

These potatoes have long been a beloved menu item at El Quinto Pino. It’s basically just a dish consisting of potatoes and a spicy aioli, and it’s delicious.

Uni Panini

A rightfully celebrated stroke of sandwich genius. This is a thin baguette stuffed with sea urchin and what tastes like wasabi, but is actually a Korean mustard oil of sorts. It’s punchy but also delicate, and it rules.


A paella dish, made with thin, angel hair type noodles instead of rice. This Fideua is also stuffed with tons of squid and shrimp. We love it.

Bikini De Huitlacoche

OK, so this is a “bikini” sandwich, which consists of cheese and something called “corn smut.” You’re not going to not order that.

Garbanzos “El Rinconcillo”

An excellent chick pea and spinach stew, served in a small dish. The garbaznos are smoky and delicious, and this should be on your table.

Featured in

The One-Two Punch: A Date Night Dinner & Drinks Guide guide image

The One-Two Punch: A Date Night Dinner & Drinks Guide

The Best Tapas Places In NYC guide image

The Best Tapas Places In NYC

15 Great NYC Neighborhood Restaurants guide image

15 Great NYC Neighborhood Restaurants

Suggested Reading

Bar Jamón review image
Bar Jamón

Bar Jamón is basically Casa Mono's waiting room. However, for that First/Early in the Game Date, where dinner feels too formal but you are also starving, Bar Jamón was designed for you.

La Vara review image

La Vara is the best Spanish restaurant in Brooklyn, and possibly all of New York City.

Tia Pol review image

Tia Pol is a Chelsea tapas spot that’s a great move for early-in-the-game dates. Have some sangria and some small plates.

Txikito review image

Txikito has been doing solid business in Chelsea for several years, serving Basque-style tapas to people who are mostly on dates.

Infatuation Logo
2023 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store