NYCReview

Cafe Gitane review image

Cafe Gitane

$$$$

242 Mott St, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

Cafe Gitane is the epitome of the “it” downtown cafe - a quintessential Nolita eatery and place to See And Be Seen that so many places try (and fail) to replicate. The food is actually pretty good. Dinner can be underwhelming, but brunch is solid, and the prices aren’t as bad as you might expect. But Cafe Gitane isn’t for everyone. The place is tiny, and staring down a bunch of really hot people while you cram your fat ass into a little chair isn’t always awesome. You are also pretty much guaranteed to face long waits, but during the summer it’s a great warm weather dining destination, and can be worth hanging around for a table on the street or near one of the big windows. Especially if you’re looking to drink some coffee and watch the action go by.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Cafe Gitane review image

Baked Eggs

Served with basil, tomato, and cream, it’s the tangy tomato sauce that makes this dish. The eggs get nice and crisp on the outside edges and absorb the sauce and flavor in the middle. It’s a must to get some crusty bread for dunkage.

Orange Blossom Waffle

Orange blossom waffle? What? Don’t worry about it. Just order it. Topped with bananas, blueberries, and strawberries, this big circular waffle looks like it came out of the same waffle maker you got off your wedding registry. You’re welcome.

Granola with Raisins, Cashews, Fresh Fruit and Yogurt

I admit there is nothing unique or original about this dish. You can find it on pretty much every brunch menu in town, but Cafe Gitane does good work with the basics.

Arugula, Beets, Apple, Olives & Walnuts Salad

Every restaurant in NYC has some play on this salad, and this one is head and shoulders above the competition. Everything about it is on point, from the fresh ingredients to the portion size. If you’re going salad, get this one.

Baked Feta

Served with capers, thyme, olives, and tomatoes, this is one of the better “petit plats” on the menu. This part of the menu is straightforward; what you see is what you get. Brie & Apple? A couple slices of cheese, a couple slices of apple. The plats are a great way to start the meal or snack on while enjoying a coffee, just don’t expect to have your mind blown.

Cafe Gitane review image

Avacado on Seven Grain Toast

Another “plat” (I really like writing that) not to miss. An excellent dish to share, this toast is topped with avocado, lemon juice, olive oil, and chili flakes. Excellent.

Cafe Gitane review image

Moroccan Couscous

One of their more popular specialties, this (sometimes leaning) tower of couscous is served with red peppers, raisins, toasted pine nuts, hummus, and eggplant. We prefer the chicken add-on as opposed to the Merguez sausage, although both are pretty solid.

Featured in

Where To Take An Out-Of-Towner (When You’re Tired) guide image
Guide
Where To Take An Out-Of-Towner (When You’re Tired)

The next time a friend comes to town and you’re low on energy, try one of these spots.

14 Great Healthy Lunch Options Downtown guide image
Guide
14 Great Healthy Lunch Options Downtown

Where to go for a lunch downtown that won’t make you feel terrible for the rest of the day.

The Kind-Of-Healthy Brunch Guide guide image
Guide
The Kind-Of-Healthy Brunch Guide

The places to hit when you want brunch, but don’t want to be in a food coma the rest of the day.

Suggested Reading

Egg Shop review image
Review
Egg Shop

People are waiting an hour for egg sandwiches at Nolita’s Egg Shop. Is it worth it? Time to investigate.

Tartinery review image
Review
Tartinery

The food at Tartinery isn’t nearly good enough to make you look past the fact that it’s just some dude’s idea of a girl’s ideal restaurant.

The Smile review image
Review
The Smile

This cafe in NoHo is and always has been where New York City’s most attractively unemployed people come to have breakfast at noon.

Jack's Wife Freda West Village review image
Review
Jack's Wife Freda West Village

The new West Village outpost of Jack's Wife Freda is the same as the original, with a bigger, more comfortable space.