NYCReview

photo credit: Adrian Gaut

Broken Shaker review image

Broken Shaker

$$$$

23 Lexington Ave, New York
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points
RESERVE A TABLE

POWERED BY

open table

Broken Shaker is a rooftop bar, but it isn’t a place where you’ll have to shout over loud music while someone spills a vodka Red Bull on your new shoes. It gets packed, sure - but it feels less like a typical rooftop bar and more like a house party in a nice, beach-themed apartment that you somehow got invited to. It’s on top of the Freehand Hotel on Lexington Ave, and there’s a big indoor space with plenty of tables and bars on either side, as well as a large wraparound terrace with even more tables. You can either sit and order food (like a burger with yucca fries and a tray of uni), or you can just grab a drink at one of the bars and enjoy the views. That said, you should get here early, or mentally prepare for a long wait. The good news is, it’s worth it.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Featured in

The Best NYC Bars Where You Can Dance guide image
Guide
The Best NYC Bars Where You Can Dance

27 spots where you can practice those dance moves you learned from YouTube.

The Best Rooftop Bars In NYC guide image
Guide
The Best Rooftop Bars In NYC

Where to drink when you want a panoramic view of the city.

Where To Go Out When You Don’t Go Out Anymore guide image
Guide
Where To Go Out When You Don’t Go Out Anymore

12 bars for when you’ve reached the point in your life where you look forward to sleeping on Friday nights.

A New Rooftop Bar In The East Village + More NYC Roof Reopenings guide image
Guide
A New Rooftop Bar In The East Village + More NYC Roof Reopenings

5 new and newly-reopened rooftop bars where you can hang out this summer in NYC.

Suggested Reading

22 Affordable Places To Impress An Out-Of-Towner guide image
Guide
22 Affordable Places To Impress An Out-Of-Towner

All the best places where you can eat with a tourist without having to spend an upsetting amount of money.

Where To Have Drinks Around Flatiron guide image
Guide
Where To Have Drinks Around Flatiron

Need to drink in Flatiron? Here’s where to do it.

Rooftop Reds review image
Review
Rooftop Reds

Rooftop Reds is a reservation-only rooftop wine bar in the Brooklyn Navy Yard with hammocks and cornhole.

Good Story Rooftop Lounge review image
Review
Good Story Rooftop Lounge

Good Story is the rooftop bar at the Arlo Soho hotel, and, as far as rooftop bars go, it’s a pretty pleasant place to hang with a group downtown.