Bayville, Long Island - 70 minutes from Midtown

Unfortunately, no haunted house will truly be able to compete with the nightmare that is 2020. But if you’re looking for a close second on Long Island, you can try Bayville Scream Park. This year, they have walk-through and drive-through haunted house options, in case you’d rather not leave your car. There’s also zombie axe throwing, which sounds both terrifying and therapeutic.