New York City’s Best New Restaurants Of 2016

New York City’s best new restaurants of 2016, according to us.
New York City’s Best New Restaurants Of 2016 image

photo credit: Noah Devereaux

A lot of restaurants opened in New York City in 2016, and a good amount of them left us feeling like that shrug emoticon we can never exactly remember how to type. But a handful - particularly the ten listed here - were exciting, fun, and delicious. These are the highly-rated new restaurants that are actually worth a trip across town. Among them are a surprising three French restaurants (it’s 1986 again!), a Peruvian restaurant, a Korean restaurant, one place making “new American” feel not-boring anymore, and even a bagel shop. There’s pizza and pasta worth getting excited about too.

To give you a better sense of what these places actually look like (rather than just show you some picture of a random appetizer), we partnered up with Samsung and used their immersive Gear 360 cameras to drop you right into the center of each restaurant on the list. Take a look around, and see what restaurants you need to get on your list.

Presented in partnership with Samsung.



$$$$Perfect For:Date NightDinner with the ParentsEating At The BarSee And Be SeenSpecial Occasions
Earn 3x points with your sapphire card

Pasquale Jones is not an Italian restaurant. And it’s not a pizza restaurant. Pasquale Jones is a wine restaurant. A wine restaurant that happens to serve exceptional food. It’s from the team behind Charlie Bird, and we were initially worried that their second venture wouldn’t live up the original. Turns out it’s even better. And that’s because, in addition to a best-in-city wine list, an upscale but relaxed vibe, and the best clam pizza you’ll probably ever eat, Pasquale Jones gets all the other details right too. If you haven’t made it here yet, this is how you close out 2016 on a high note.

In 100 years, when cars fly themselves and the robots - excuse us, bots - have taken over, they’ll look back on 2016 and study Olmsted. This restaurant is the culmination of everything humans get excited about right now, from their obsession with hyper-seasonal, hyper-local ingredients to the string-light garden to the DIY crayfish farm (AKA bathtub) in that garden. But as of-the-moment as Olmsted might feel, we’d also bet all our money it’s not going anywhere. This restaurant mixes incredible, unusual food with an incredibly approachable, laid-back environment - it’s a place that’s serious about food but doesn’t take itself too seriously. Your move, bots.

There are select moments in life that call for bringing out the Big Guns. Important dates, anniversaries, birthdays, dinner with parents who still aren’t convinced you’re a successful adult - these times call for a restaurant that, in both food and vibe, will blow all parties away. Lilia is such a restaurant. Make a reservation (no one is impressed by two-hour waits), fill your table with simple, excellent pastas, order a negroni or three, and you’ll be in one of the greatest setups we have in this town.

One way to think of Le Coucou is that it’s a fancy restaurant for people who don’t like fancy restaurants. The food is capital-s Serious and French, but there’s no tasting menu and the servers will talk to you like a normal human, and not like you’re one of the daughters on Downton Abbey. Everything about a meal here ends up feeling capital-s Special, from the pretty much flawless food to the service to the overall fancy but still not-stuffy vibes. There’s no other restaurant like this in New York right now. Book your 2017 birthday/anniversary dinners here now.

One of our main complaints about New York City restaurants over the past few years is that so many of them are the same. Serve a few pastas and a branzino, throw in some leather booths, and call it a day. We definitely don’t have that complaint about Llama Inn, which serves a modern take on Peruvian food in a very cool space under the BQE in Williamsburg. The quinoa here comes mixed with banana and bacon, you can eat a beef heart skewer (or some ceviche, if that’s not your thing), and the room, with plants hanging from the ceilings and a big tangled-up tapestry thing covering one wall, is actually interesting. Each time we go back, the food seems to get even better.

A tiny French restaurant in Greenwich Village, Mimi manages to be a restaurant that’s simultaneously a sexy, vibey place to drink an ice cold martini, and also a place to eat pork head, crispy cod sperm, or blood sausage. The menu changes frequently, and you’ll also find tuna and roast chicken alongside the monkfish liver and venison. See it in 360.

Manhattan has Russ & Daughters, and Katz’s, and Sadelle’s, and Barney Greengrass. Brooklyn real iconic places to get lox on a bagel. But when Frankel’s opened early this year, it changed that. This is a modern neighborhood Jewish deli that already feels like a classic. And it’s the rare place that’s as useful as it is delicious - it’s affordable, it’s easy, and the pastrami-cured lox, pastrami/egg/cheese sandwich, and latkes (and mostly everything else on the menu) are worth the trip to Greenpoint.



OpenTable logo

You have to be kind of stupid to open a pizza restaurant in NYC. There are somewhere in the neighborhood of 5,837 pizza spots in this city, and there is an extremely low likelihood that you’ll be able to serve something that either A) competes with the best or B) is actually unique. Leave it to the people behind one of our all-time favorite places (Emily) to accomplish both A and B with Emmy Squared. The pizza here is Detroit-style, meaning it’s square-cut and thick, fried on the outside, fluffy-molten on the inside, with gooey cheese and spots of sauce on top and crispy bits on the edges. That, and their spicy fried chicken sandwich, are some of the most enjoyable things we put in our mouths this year.

Want to celebrate the end of 2016 with us? We’ll be throwing a big year-end event at 837, Samsung’s experience center in the Meatpacking District, and we’ll have some space for the Infatuation faithful to party with us. Sign up for our newsletter and stay tuned for more info:

Chase Sapphire Card Ad

Suggested Reading

2016 Observations and 2017 Predictions image

2016 Observations and 2017 Predictions

A look back on what’s transpired, and what the new year might hold.

Mimi image

A sexy Greenwich Village restaurant with an unusual French menu. Your next date night should be at Mimi.

Lilia image

The only real reason to fuss over getting a table at Lilia is their simple, perfect pasta.

Frankel’s Delicatessen image

Frankel’s is a Jewish deli in the same vein as Russ & Daughters, but on its own level entirely.

Infatuation Logo


2024 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The views and opinions expressed on The Infatuation’s site and other platforms are those of the authors and do not reflect the official policy or position of (or endorsement by) JPMorgan Chase. The Infatuation and its affiliates assume no responsibility or liability for the content of this site, or any errors or omissions. The Information contained in this site is provided on an "as is" basis with no guarantees of completeness, accuracy, usefulness or timeliness.


Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store