Most of the live music joints on Broadway fall in the “style-over-substance” category (“style” is used very loosely here). Happily, The Twelve Thirty Club is that rare Broadway spot that aces both. There’s a rooftop and honkytonk here, but you’ll want to focus your attention on the supper club, an old-school throwback run by Mr. Suit-and-Tie himself, Justin Timberlake. The menu pulls in some of those classic supper club dishes—prime rib, dry-aged ribeyes, seafood towers, and scalloped potatoes—while also having a surprisingly good collection of dishes like the 12/30 Roll with crispy black rice, truffle fries, and wagyu bolognese, not to mention an excellent Old Fashioned.