If we could only eat one burger in Maui for the rest of our lives, it would be from Teddy’s Bigger Burgers. Look past the brightly-colored interior and multi-colored booths that look like a chain where you might find a play-place, because the patties here are made from high-quality meat that’s hand-pattied daily, charbroiled to order, and served on freshly toasted potato buns from a local bakery. Teddy’s burgers come in three sizes - from Big (third of a pound) to Bigger (half-pound) to Biggest (a one-pound double behemoth) - and they also have hand-cut fries, crispy chicken sandwiches, and salads, as well as milkshakes and root beer floats like we expect from any classic burger spot.
Where we've featured it
More spots in LahainaSee more
Mala Ocean Tavern
Mala is so close to the shoreline you’ll feel like you’re eating on top of the water - come with a few people and order lots of tapas-style dishes.
Star Noodle House, at the top of the Lahaina Business Park, is our favorite noodle house on the island.
More American spotsSee more
Open at 5am, Kihei Caffe is one of the island’s most popular breakfast spots so expect a wait for large portions of pancakes, biscuits, and scrambles.
Suggested by our writers
808 On Main
When you need a break from spending a ton of money but still want great food, head to 808 on Main for a sandwich.
South Maui Fish Company
South Maui Fish Company is just a food truck with a couple tables and chair set up around, but it serves some of the best and freshest poke.
Maui Brewing Company
The largest craft brewery in Hawaii, Maui Brewing Company in Kihei’s flagship restaurant is a huge, open-air space great for groups and families.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more