LAReview

Here’s the thing about fresh seafood: You don’t have to do much to it. Any accountant can watch a YouTube video about shucking oysters, go to a fish market, and make something almost as good as what they’d get at a restaurant. On the other hand, even the best chefs can go too far overboard, and ruin a fresh spiny lobster with a gallon of cream and a sprinkling of gold flakes. Historic South Central’s Holbox occupies the sweet spot between the two. This wholly original Mexican restaurant serves impeccable seafood, with thoughtful details that showcase the fish - but never outshine it.

This order-at-the-counter spot is at Mercado La Paloma, in the Figueroa Corridor near USC. There are plenty of other great stalls here (especially Chichen Itza, a Yucatecan spot from the same chef), but Holbox is the best restaurant in the market, as it would be in just about any other market in LA.

You’ll find a bunch of great stuff on the menu. This includes a bowl of buttery-soft Baja scallops and avocado that’s doused in lime/serrano/cilantro aguachile, and a smoked fish tostada with yellowtail, shrimp, and scallop, topped with diced onions, avocado crema, peanuts, and some deadly hot chile de arbol. There’s a whole section of tacos that are worth your time, too. Among our favorites is the rockfish, deep-fried then topped with cabbage, salsa roja, and crema, that’s as great as anything you’d get in Ensenada, and scallop and octopus ones that are nothing like you’ll find anywhere else (but are just as good).

We will say, there are a couple misses on this menu, too - we’d avoid the wood-grilled kanpachi taco and the torta de camarón. The kanpachi is usually overdone, resulting in dry, too-flaky fish, and the torta just involves entirely too much bread to taste the shrimp. On the whole, though, this menu (available all day, every day) is good, and often great.

Holbox review image

Simplicity is a common thread throughout the meal, but your experience at Holbox is enhanced, and even defined, by the specific details - the peanuts adding a necessary crunch to the smoked fish tostada, or the fragrance of saffron deepening the flavor in the mussels stew. When things slip here - rarely, and usually at lunch - it’s when those details get lost. When Holbox is at its best, tiny specific details allow the seafood to shine brightly. There’s an art to the simplicity and the restraint - and you’ll never learn that just from a YouTube video.

Food Rundown

Clams And Oysters On The Half-Shell

If you’re here for the tasting menu - and you should be, at least once - this will likely be your first course. From the two savory oysters, served without dressing (and so good that we don’t want any), to the blood clams topped with smoky morita, and the sweet giant surf clam with house-made cocktail sauce, this is the best way we know to start a meal.

Holbox review image

Tacos

Besides the fried fish, our favorites are the scallop and the octopus. That octopus is braised, fried, and served over ink sofrito. It’s among the best in a city full of great tacos, as is the Maine diver scallop with pickled fennel.

Holbox review image

Ceviche Mixto

Ceviche might not be your top choice here - it’s usually pretty straightforward, right? Wrong. This one with shrimp, octopus, and rockfish is acidic, bold, and bright. The fantastic kick from the arbol-guajillo salsa underneath rounds it out well.

Kanpachi And Uni Tostada

An excellent Baja-style lime-and-red-onion-heavy sea bass ceviche, topped with uni, and served on a tostada. We highly approve. At dinner, this is served in a still-moving urchin, which we approve of even more highly.

Holbox review image

Pulpo Asado

The springy, crunchy meatiness of the tentacle balances perfectly with the almond pepian - a supremely nutty mole - it’s served with. The caramelized pepitas on top give it an added layer of sweet crunch.

Holbox review image

Scallop Aguachile

Lunch or dinner, don’t skip this dish under any circumstances. If they bottled the aguachile, we’d bring it home and use it as a marinade, a cocktail mixer, and probably a mouthwash, too.

Holbox review image

Carabinero

A meaty, absolutely massive prawn that’s rare to find in restaurants, and even rarer to see at $15 a pop. They don’t show up on the menu even when they have them, so make sure you check the seafood case before you order.

Featured in

.
The 25 Best Restaurants In LA guide image
Guide
The 25 Best Restaurants In LA

Meet our 25 highest-rated restaurants.

The First Timer’s Guide To Eating In LA guide image
Guide
The First Timer’s Guide To Eating In LA

These restaurants will help you get acquainted with Los Angeles.

The Day-Off Lunch Guide guide image
Guide
The Day-Off Lunch Guide

Where to get a weekday meal when you don’t have to work.

11 Great LA Seafood Markets For Pick-Up & Delivery guide image
Guide
11 Great LA Seafood Markets For Pick-Up & Delivery

These seafood markets have got everything you need for grilling, poaching, and pan-searing.

Suggested Reading

.
La Carmencita review image
Review
La Carmencita

La Carmencita is a much-needed neighborhood Mexican spot in the heart of Hollywood.

B.S. Taqueria review image
Review
B.S. Taqueria

B.S. might be the casual brother to Broken Spanish, but it is every bit as fantastic.

EMC Seafood And Raw Bar review image
Review
EMC Seafood And Raw Bar

EMC Raw Bar is a weird, cool, and downright fun Ktown seafood restaurant where even the pickiest eaters in your group will walk out happy.

Fishwives review image
Review
Fishwives

Fishwives in Pasadena is serving a lot of fish, but you should stick to the crab rolls if you’re in the area.