Unlike the staggering amount of Indian restaurants in NYC, they’re more spread out in the Hudson Valley. Cinnamon is your best option in Rhinebeck for dishes like saag paneer, lamb biryani, and goat cheese naan. We’ve visited when they had a buffet with a ton of vegetarian and meat offerings, but there’s still plenty to choose from off their big menu. Plus, they make it really easy to customize any dish to your preferred spice level—and show how hot certain plates are with cute little chili peppers. They've got individual tables, but there is a large one meant for communal meals, so it's great for bigger groups or large parties.