CHIReview

Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream review image
8.1

Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream

$$$$

960 W 31st St, Chicago
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream was supposed to open in April, but, well, the pandemic. After months of operating as a pop-up (and waiting to see WTF would happen with the planet), they finally opened a walk-up window and back patio in Bridgeport. Which is great, because now we can eat their fantastic pizza whenever we want.

This place focuses on three things (those three things should be self-explanatory) and we’ll start with the one we’re the most excited about - the pizza. It’s Sicilian pan-style, and what makes it exceptional is the excellent crust. It’s thick and airy, with a golden brown undercarriage - almost like it’s been fried, but not too greasy. There are four kinds to choose from (cheese, sausage, veggie, and a weekly special like soppressata with fennel), and you can either order a full pie or by-the-slice. However you decide to do it, this pizza needs to be in your life.

As much as we love the pizza, the chicken should be invited to the party, too. The buttermilk batter is from Kimski (which is right next door), and you can get it as a meal or a sandwich. Both are valid options, but the sandwich is made with the fantastic buns from Butter Dough in McKinley Park, and the buttery softness of the bread combined with the crunchy chicken is a pretty outstanding combination.

Now, onto the ice cream. It’s from Pretty Cool, which is easy to find around the city these days. Does that mean you should skip it here? Absolutely not. Clearly, nothing goes better with pizza and fried chicken than ice cream. After all, you heard it here first.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream review image

Pizza

This place has some of the best Sicilian pan-style pizza in Chicago. It’s rectangular, with a delicious, thick, golden-brown crust and you can order it as a whole pie or by-the-slice. And all but the veggie are made with their slightly spicy, house-made red sauce.

Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream review image

Fried Chicken Sandwich

You can get a three or six-piece fried chicken dinner (it comes with potato salad or slaw), or a sandwich that’s made with a breast, mayo, lettuce, pickled onions, and fries. The chicken is spicy and crunchy, and very good. It’s also very large.

Ice Cream

They have a lot of different flavors (around 10) of Pretty Cool Ice Cream’s popsicles and bars here. So if you can’t find something that sounds good, that’s probably on you.

Featured in

The Best Tavern-Style Pizza In Chicago guide image
Guide
The Best Tavern-Style Pizza In Chicago

Our favorite spots for tavern-style pizza in the city.

The Most Exciting New Delivery Options In Chicago guide image
Guide
The Most Exciting New Delivery Options In Chicago

Bored of ordering the same thing? Order takeout from one of these spots.

8 New Things To Do & Eat In Chicago This Week guide image
Guide
8 New Things To Do & Eat In Chicago This Week

Check out these new openings, pop-ups, and special events happening in Chicago from May 4th to May 11th.

Where To Eat & Drink When You’re Remembering How To Socialize guide image
Guide
Where To Eat & Drink When You’re Remembering How To Socialize

21 spots where you can be a social butterfly who has just emerged from the cocoon you call an apartment.

Suggested Reading

Gotham Bagels review image
8.2
Review
Gotham Bagels

Gotham is a fantastic carryout bagel spot in Old Town.

Han Burger: A New Takeout-Only Spot We Love feature image
Feature
Han Burger: A New Takeout-Only Spot We Love

Here’s what you should order.

Chicago Restaurant Closings feature image
Feature
Chicago Restaurant Closings

Chicago restaurants that have closed during the coronavirus pandemic.

The Best Ice Cream Shops In Chicago guide image
Guide
The Best Ice Cream Shops In Chicago

Where to go for ice cream in Chicago.