BOSReview

photo credit: Emily Schindler

Belle Isle Seafood review image

Belle Isle Seafood

$$$$

1 Main St, Winthrop
View WebsiteEarn 3X Points

Hey, look over there - past the gas station, the parking lot filled with squawking seagulls, the chain-link fence that shakes when planes land at Logan. See that shimmering blue expanse? That’s called the ocean, and it’s used for fun things like swimming, boating, fishing, and giving movie characters something to stare out at as they consider whether or not they should stay with their unfaithful spouse.

It’s also where you’ll find Belle Isle Seafood, a cafeteria-like space that overlooks the harbor in a small post-industrial pocket of Winthrop. And if you’re looking for some really well-made classic New England seafood - the type of fried, stuffed, and buttery food that usually tastes best when it’s topped with a thin layer of beach sand - then Belle Isle is where you want to be.

Belle Isle Seafood review image

photo credit: Emily Schindler

Located in a corrugated aluminum warehouse of a building, Belle Isle looks more like a fish processing plant than a restaurant. It sort of smells like one too, because in addition to being a restaurant, it’s also a fish market, a place to pick up some fresh cod fillets or stuffed quahogs while being watched by a plastic pirate. But if you come here for the fish market, you’ll then have to do the cooking yourself, and here’s the thing: you’re not as good at it as they are. So feel free to grab some fresh halibut, but don’t leave without stuffing your face with things like fried clams, chowder, and something called a lobster pie, which is every bit as good as it sounds.

There’s hardly a dud on the menu. You can go with the lobster roll that’s roughly the size of your face and uses a perfectly toasted bun, the fried seafood platter that’s stuffed with more fish than the New England Aquarium, or the little fried smelts that don’t carry a hint of grease. Either way it’s going to be good, because it’s going to be fresh, pulled right out of the ocean you’re sitting next to (hopefully during the summer, when you can enjoy their outdoor picnic tables). There’s a reason we built this city next to a cold, windy sea. Belle Isle Seafood is that reason.

Sign up for our newsletter.

Be the first to get expert restaurant recommendations for every situation right in your inbox.


By signing up, I agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Food Rundown

Belle Isle Seafood review image

photo credit: Emily Schindler

Chowder

It’s creamy, it’s got a solid clam-to-potato ratio, and it’s a good example as to why many people think the Massachusetts state flag should just be a bowl of chowder with some crackers in it.

Belle Isle Seafood review image

photo credit: Emily Schindler

Lobster Roll

We can’t say with 100% certainty that it’s the biggest lobster roll in Boston, but the fact that it’s in the discussion should be all you need to hear.

Belle Isle Seafood review image

photo credit: Emily Schindler

Lobster Pie

It’s a plate of big, juicy chunks of lobster baked with breadcrumbs and butter, and we demand that it be on our table next Thanksgiving.

Fried Seafood Platter

The fried seafood here is crunchy and free of grease. You won’t be able to decide which one to get, so get the platter that comes with shrimp, scallops, squid, clams, and haddock.

Featured in

Where To Eat And Drink By The Water In Boston guide image
Guide
Where To Eat And Drink By The Water In Boston

The best places to eat and drink while imagining that you own a boat.

The Best Seafood Restaurants in Boston That Aren't Legal Seafood guide image
Guide
The Best Seafood Restaurants in Boston That Aren't Legal Seafood

We have nothing against Legal’s, but Boston has way more interesting places to get some excellent seafood - like these 11 restaurants.

The Best Restaurants in East Boston guide image
Guide
The Best Restaurants in East Boston

13 spots not named “Logan.”

Suggested Reading

Legal Harborside review image
Review
Legal Harborside

Legal Harborside is a giant seafood restaurant in the Seaport, with multiple dining concepts and a big roof deck with harbor views.

Neptune Oyster review image
Review
Neptune Oyster

Neptune Oyster is a ridiculously popular oyster bar in the North End. It’s worth it if you can get in.

Island Creek Oyster Bar review image
Review
Island Creek Oyster Bar

Island Creek Oyster Bar is a quintessential Boston seafood restaurant.

Saltie Girl review image
Review
Saltie Girl

Saltie Girl is a small, excellent seafood restaurant in Back Bay with a fun bar.

Infatuation Logo
2023 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.

FIND PLACES ON OUR APP

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store