It’s about time we got to Roberta’s. It is, after all, a ridiculously cool restaurant run by former musicians with a radio station in the back. But for about two years, I thought this was a soul food destination in a part of Brooklyn that I also thought was where the airport was. I should probably look at a map/the internet more often.
So while I was a bit disappointed to learn that Roberta’s would not be another place for me to get delicious fried chicken and red velvet cake, I was very excited to find that this is basically a hipster’s Chuck E. Cheese. The restaurant has everything a self respecting Brooklynite could ever want – a big wood burning oven, a self-sustaining roof garden, loud music, communal tables, craft beers, pizza – I kind of expected to see a ball pit made just for dudes in short shorts out back. But the most impressive thing of all is how incredibly good our meal was here. We had some of the best pizza we’ve ever had at Roberta’s, and that’s after being hyped like crazy on the place. Somehow, the food actually might be better than what you’ve heard. Don’t believe me? Just take a look at Yelp. Not even those crazies can find a reason to whine about this place, and they get upset if a waiter blinks too often or forgets to recognize their “eliteness.” Just know going in that you’re going to wait for a table, and you should come away very happy. Also, make sure to get there before the summer is over. Roberta’s has one of the best Outdoor/Patio Situations in town.
White and Green Pizza
A delicious pizza with mozzarella, arugula, lemon and parmigiano. We loved a pizza piled high with greens, and this one did not disappoint.
Rainbow Connection Pizza
Another pizza with some greens, this one consists mostly of wilted rainbow chard and mozzarella, with some garlic and breadcrumbs thrown in for good measure. It was a split decision at the table…that chard has a little bitterness to it that some like and some don’t. I would hit something else next time.
Axl Rosenberg Pizza
Holy sh*t. This is one of the best pies we’ve eaten anywhere. Tomato, mozzarella, double garlic, mushrooms, jalapeños, and sopressata picante all combine for what tastes like the best supreme pizza ever. Those jalapeños make it. An absolute must order, even if you’re scared of spicy.
Black Truffle Agnolotti
We decided to try some pasta to go along with all that pizza, and this black truffle dish was the winner. It’s a small plate of delicate pasta, and it’s heavy on the butter and truffles, but we liked it. That shouldn’t come as a surprise.
You Might Also Like
Yes, it can be annoying to deal with an unpredictable situation, but for a pizza this good, we're willing to deal with it. Lucali is incredible.
Our NYC pizza power rankings have forever changed. Emily not only has some of the best pizza in the city, it's also got one of the best burgers. That means you should probably get there soon.
If you don't live in NY, you might have some spot in your ‘hood that does a decent Neapolitan pie. You might even be able to find a respectable slice from time to time. But you do not have a Paulie Gee’s. And we feel sorry for you.
Is this the best pizza in New York City? We're not dumb enough to make that bold claim. This is, however, our most frequented pizza joint in town.
Speedy Romeo is the best restaurant you haven’t been to. Put it on your Hit List and make the trip to Clinton Hill. Then feel free to thank us. On second thought, thank them.
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a new favorite BBQ spot. Situated inside what used to be an old auto body shop, this gutted garage is raging every night of the week.
Don’t be fooled by the name, Fritzl’s Lunch Box isn’t just a silly sandwich counter that serves grilled cheese for lunch. It’s a real restaurant, with a real chef, and most importantly, a meat sandwich worth taking the L out to Bushwick for.
Is Lucali's South Slope sibling restaurant as good as the original?
Ridgewood's hottest pizza hangout. Is it the next Roberta's?
Rocky Slims has the best pizza in Murray Hill, but it's also got some baggage that comes along with the location.